The rhetorical work of credibility-building for social scientific big data: Positioning arguments and legitimacy in empirical sociology
Loading...
Access rights
openAccess
publishedVersion
URL
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
A1 Alkuperäisartikkeli tieteellisessä aikakauslehdessä
This publication is imported from Aalto University research portal.
View publication in the Research portal (opens in new window)
View/Open full text file from the Research portal (opens in new window)
Other link related to publication (opens in new window)
View publication in the Research portal (opens in new window)
View/Open full text file from the Research portal (opens in new window)
Other link related to publication (opens in new window)
Authors
Date
2020-12
Department
Major/Subject
Mcode
Degree programme
Language
en
Pages
36
Series
STS Encounters, Volume 11, issue 1, pp. 281-316
Abstract
This article investigates the rhetorical work of building credibility for social scientific research designs with big data. Big data is discussed as a contested concept in the social sciences, one whose meaning and implications are under dispute. Proceeding from analysis of 29 sociology articles based on empirical research, the author argues that credibility is constructed in this context through the rhetorical positioning of disciplines as legitimate interpreters of big data. The article identifies three distinct positioning strategies: conservative, reformist, and supplementarist, each of which locates the legitimacy of interpretation in its own way. While conservative positioning fixes the locus of legitimate interpretation within the social sciences, those employing a reformist strategy seek to widen it to encompass methods from beyond established social scientific fields. Finally, supplementarist positioning portrays big data as inherently limited and ties the legitimacy of interpretation to alternative approaches. Through identifying and addressing these respective strategies, the article discusses rhetorical positioning as part of the work of enacting big data: a performative process that can foster several visions of the future methodology of the social sciences.Description
Keywords
Other note
Citation
Pääkkönen, J 2020, ' The rhetorical work of credibility-building for social scientific big data : Positioning arguments and legitimacy in empirical sociology ', STS Encounters, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 281-316 .